Company law is widely understood to be a creature of statute law. The Companies Act 2006, like the Companies Act 1948, is a monumental piece of consolidating legislative work. Who can forget being confronted with a statute book several inches thick? Cases, however, have played a central role in creating, establishing and influencing legal ideas that were later enshrined within legislation. Despite the extensive literature on landmark cases, company law has hitherto escaped our attention. Landmark Cases in Company Law aims to address this imbalance. It examines the cases that come together to make up the field of company law. The chapters explore the historical circumstances that brought these disputes before the courts in more detail than has been achieved before. Several also reconsider the significance of the judgments within the broader schema of doctrinal development.
Even having set an aim of unearthing landmark cases in company law, it is difficult to discern what exactly a landmark case is (or not). The concept of a landmark case is usually treated as being open to interpretation. This book is designed to sit alongside the company law curriculum and have a strong relationship to law-making and legal education in the present. We propose to introduce a selection method that is new, sophisticated and innovative and is objective. We select the cases used most by leading textbook writers rather than those used most in the courtroom to reflect our focus on the company law curriculum. The textbooks assessed to build the analysis are:
- Dignam & Lowry, Company Law,
- Hannigan, Company Law,
- Mayson, French & Ryan on Company Law,
- Pettet, Lowry & Reisberg’s Company Law,
- Sealy & Worthington’s Text, Cases, and Materials in Company Law
We have used the latest textbook edition at the start date of our project, which began in 2021. Our selection process is intended to be democratic in nature. We, as editors, develop a system through which we rely upon the views of others to determine our cases. We deliberately opt to employ a range of other scholars in the field (and their work) to tell us what cases are central to company law as opposed to imposing our own view of what company law is (or not) onto the volume. That said, the process, which identifies the top cited cases, has not eliminated the need for editorial judgment entirely. We have still had to exercise some judgment to narrow this down to a manageable number of cases for a volume like this. These are the chapters for the collection:
- Foss v Harbottle (1843) – Susan Watson and Lynn Buckley
- Salomon v Salomon (1897) – Marc Moore
- Allen v Gold Reefs of West Africa Ltd (1900) – Adaeze Okoye
- Burland v Earle (1902) – Victoria Barnes and Richard McBride
- Quin & Axtens v Salmon (1909) – Jonathan Hardman
- Hickman v Kent or Romney Marsh Sheepbreeders’ Association Ltd (1915) – Eva Micheler
- Cook v Deeks (1916) – Camden Hutchison
- Re City Equitable Fire Insurance Company (1925) – Andrew Keay
- Greenhalgh v Arderne Cinemas Ltd [1951] – Daniel Attenborough
- Bushell v Faith (1970) – David Cabrelli
- Ebrahimi v Westbourne Galleries Ltd (1973) – Alan Dignam
- Howard Smith Ltd v Ampol Petroleum Ltd (1974) – Andrew Johnston
- Siebe Gorman & Co Ltd v Barclays Bank Ltd (1978) – Sarah Paterson
- Re Brightlife Ltd (1987) – Joan Loughrey
- Smith v Croft (No 2) (1988) – Arad Reisberg
- Re Produce Marketing (1989) – Pey-Woan Lee
- In Re Sevenoaks Stationers (Retail) Ltd (1990) – Sally Wheeler
- Adams v Cape Industries (1990) – Duncan Wallace
- Russell v Northern Bank Development Corporation Ltd and others (1992) – Blanaid Clarke
- O’Neill v Phillips (1999) – Paddy Ireland
The chapters are worth reading for a variety of different reasons. Several shed new light on well-known cases; they tell this familiar story in a different way and so the chapter is compelling and even exciting to read. The chapters, which bring the litigants and their stories to life, move the case reports as what would have once been the principal accounts of these disputes into mere starting points. The chapters here give far a richer and more lively historical understanding. The chapters by Marc Moore, Susan Watson and Lynn Buckley, and Camden Hutchison are worth pointing to in this regard. This, of course, was one of the aims in gathering this scholarship. The other was to see if we could find the cases at the root of company law. So to what extent has our rather cumbersome and labour-intensive empirical method resulted in the identification of landmark cases?
Several of the authors here were comfortable describing the case as a landmark. Eva Micheler does so confidently. She thinks Hickman (1915) is still a good authority. Her chapter places that case in the long view as she recreates the post-Hickman (1915) judicial treatment and establishes its place within academic and scholarly commentary. Sally Wheeler sees Re Sevenoaks Stationers (Retail) Ltd (1990) as a landmark case. This is not because it confirms the application of the Company Directors Disqualification Act section 6 to a factual matrix that fairly clearly fitted within its ambit. Several of these cases are earmarked as precipices, tipping points and pivotal moments preceding broader legal change. Sarah Paterson argues that ‘Siebe Gorman (1978) remains a landmark case, notwithstanding that it was comprehensively overruled by the decision of the House of Lords in Spectrum Plus (2005). Siebe Gorman (1978) marks the point where two roads diverge.’ There are cases that are thought to be landmarks, and indeed are, but for the wrong reasons. Daniel Attenborough’s view of Greenhalgh (1951) is just that. He answers the question of whether Greenhalgh (1951) is a landmark in the opening line. He is certain that it clearly is a landmark case. ‘Few legal cases have influenced… the structure of English company law [more]’, he says. In sum, those mistaken interpretations can still be influential and as such have ‘landmark’ status, but this makes the scholarship on them even more important. So the view from our authors about whether these cases are, indeed, landmark cases is mixed.
Landmark cases are supposed to lead to pivotal moments for legal change and tipping points that ushered in a new era of legal thinking. The cases, which appear in this volume, are universally thought to be so. The chapters are an aid for those looking to understand tipping points in company law, but equally add something to the existing literature by uncovering new facts about litigants and challenging the case’s status in the company law curriculum. Cases can also seem, at first glance, to be an isolated but central legal incident. Alan Dignam and Paddy Ireland’s chapters are the best example of research, which provides this bridging work, linking from one case to another. In doing so, the cases become connected, giving rise to a field of law and scholarship. When taken together, the chapters in this volume put these cases into the wider history of company law, showing how it came into being as a cohesive and coherent area of law.
The authors' edited collection, Landmark Cases in Company Law, is forthcoming with Hart Publishing.
Victoria Barnes is Dean of Education for the Faculty of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences at Queen’s University Belfast.
Sally Wheeler is a Professor of Law and Vice-Chancellor of Birkbeck University London.
Share: