Book Review: Dignity, Women, and Immigration Detention

Guest post by Fatmanur Delioglu. Fatmanur is presently engaged in the pursuit of a doctoral program at the Balsillie School of International Affairs, Wilfrid Laurier University. Her academic endeavors predominantly revolve around the critical examination of border policies, the intricacies of refugee solidarity networks, and the multifaceted dynamics of gender. Within the academic sphere, Fatmanur holds the role of a PhD Support Officer within the Migration, Mobilities, and Social Politics cluster at the Balsillie School of International Affairs.

Review of Dignity, Women, and Immigration Detention by Alice Gerlach (Routledge, 2022).

In Alice Gerlach’s detailed investigation into the experiences of women who spent time in immigration detention facilities in the United Kingdom (UK), the author illuminates their psychological and emotional suffering through the prism of human dignity. The book examines the complex interactions between the experiences of women subjected to immigration detention and the idea of human dignity. The book advances a compelling thesis that highlights the systematic deterioration of women's dignity in the setting of such detention and asserts that this degradation has a substantial impact on the overall course of their life.

This book makes a significant contribution to the growing body of work on immigration, detention, and gender by providing a thorough examination of the numerous difficulties experienced by women inside these systems. This study has an empirical depth that enhances the scholarly discourse thanks to the author’s thorough research, which is supported by a background of three years of experience at HM Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) and substantial involvement with numerous detention facilities.

The author's detailed presentation of research methodology and personal encounters is the basis of the book's importance. The author has gathered the voices of individuals held in removal centers as well as those who have navigated post-detention trajectories, both within the UK and after being deported to Jamaica, through a year's worth of fieldwork and interviews with 76 women. The ethical considerations woven into the fabric of the text offer a pedagogical opportunity for researchers engaged in qualitative investigations in similar domains.

The unique feature that distinguishes this work, however, is its comprehensive approach, which goes beyond the simple depiction of the detention procedure to cover the whole range of the women's experiences. The book emphasizes a crucial point by covering both the detention phase and the ensuing time of reintegration: the effects of incarceration go beyond the temporary boundaries of incarceration. The deterioration of human dignity suffered within detention centers reverberates across the women's post-detention lives, perpetuating a cycle of degradation. The work effectively dismantles the artificial dichotomy between the two phases, illuminating the continuum of challenges faced by these women.

As aptly denoted by its title, the central thematic axis of the book revolves around the dignity of women. The author navigates this complex concept through a tripartite framework: dignity as action, dignity as possession, and dignity as a state of being. These lenses reveal that the physical layout, institutional practices, and staff relationships within detention center resemble those of penal institutions, endangering the dignity of the women in numerous ways. Women are placed side by side against a stark backdrop of barbed wire, intimidating walls, and closed doors, which provides a depressing picture of how they are treated because they are seen as criminals.

There are five chapters in the book. It starts by looking at recognized definitions of dignity, which serve as the cornerstone for human rights frameworks. The author also examines how “dignity” is understood by the Home Office and private entities managing migrant detention centers. This conceptual discussion prepares the ground for the investigation into women’s experiences that follows. In the second section, the author digs into data obtained from interviews with women who have been held in immigration detention. This chapter is essential for shedding light on the aspects of incarceration that affect women's feelings of dignity. The feelings of shame and guilt that permeate their time in these institutional environments are the main topics of conversation.

In Chapter 3, the analysis is expanded to include the lives of women in the UK after they have been released, and it looks at the long-term repercussions of immigration detention and how much the women still rely on the Home Office for assistance. The emphasis of Chapter 4 shifts to interviews with women in Jamaica, revealing the complicated issues they deal with, such as societal isolation and the long-term effects of economic hardship on their lives and the lives of their children. An emotional exploration of how self-worth and dignity can be damaged in such hard circumstances concludes this section. Finally, Chapter 5 serves as the pinnacle of the author's analysis, synthesizing various research threads to construct a holistic understanding of dignity as perceived by women who have experienced immigration detention. This progression starts with theoretical underpinnings and moves on to empirical research before coming to a scholarly conceptualization of dignity that is based on actual lived experiences.

This work’s sophisticated engagement with intersectionality and exploration of the diversity of women's experiences inside detention centers is one of its key strengths. By considering the role played by different factors and actors within this intersectionality, the author reveals how different factors and actors intersect to harm women’s dignity. The book provides evidence that the suffering endured, which spans social, psychological, and economic dimensions, continues beyond release, permeating post-release life and acting as a mechanism for state-sanctioned social exclusion. The women’s vulnerability is maintained by the uncertainty surrounding their legal status, both during and after imprisonment, which hinders their absorption into the social and economic systems and perpetuates their vulnerability.

In summation, the book stands as a cogent and comprehensive exploration of immigrant women's dignity within the context of immigration detention. The endeavor is strengthened by the author's thoughtful synthesis of theoretical insights, empirical evidence, and personal experiences. The work successfully opposes the compartmentalization of these experiences by encompassing both the period of incarceration and its protracted aftermath. The book’s important contributions to the study of gender, migration, and imprisonment, together with the author’s methodological openness, make it an essential tool for both academics and professionals.

Any comments about this post? Get in touch with us! Send us an email, or post a comment here or on Facebook. You can also tweet us.