A revival of firing squads is not the solution to America’s problem of botched injections
Posted:
Time to read:
On 30 September, Christa Pike survived two attempts by the state of Tennessee to execute her by lethal injection. The attempt has been widely described as ‘botched’, a term used when an execution produces unexpected outcomes (such as prolonged delays, unnecessary suffering or complications) in the lead up to the prisoner’s death, or in some cases, survival.
Although her case received global media coverage, Christa Pike is not the first death row prisoner whose execution by lethal injection has been botched. For example, on 21 May, Tony Carruthers survived a botched execution attempt when staff were unable to establish a second IV line (per Tennessee’s protocol) to administer the lethal injection. Botched executions involving the use of lethal injections are not just characteristic of Tennessee: data from the Death Penalty Information Center shows that there have been 16 cases across eight states in the past decade where executions using lethal injections were botched.
In April, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) released a report directing the Federal Bureau of Prisons to expand methods of execution available to states enacting capital punishment. It recommended that the catalogue of options available for selection should include the use of nitrogen gas, electrocution, and, notably as the first option, firing squads. U.S. states offering alternative means of capital punishment is not a novel development. Although lethal injections are the most common method of execution, states commonly authorise multiple methods, designating one as primary while retaining others as alternatives. For example, execution by firing squad already forms one of a catalogue of options for death row prisoners in Idaho, Utah, South Carolina, Mississippi and Oklahoma (as of July, only Idaho retains it as a primary option).
Why the push to make it an option in other states? The DOJ asserts that, first, death by firing squad is less painful than other methods and, second, the method has historically provided the fewest botched state executions. The fixation in the DOJ report on recommending execution methods based on painlessness and infallibility as principal criteria demonstrates how federal execution policy is being driven by efforts to appease the Eighth Amendment.
The Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on “cruel and unusual punishment” does not itself demand painlessness or infallibility from an execution method (the US Supreme Court has affirmed there is no right to a painless death). It does, however, permit prisoners on death row to challenge an execution method if they can show that it carries a substantial risk of severe pain and if they can also propose a feasible alternative to significantly reduce that risk. An incentive therefore exists for states to select methods that can be argued to be the least painful and most likely to work, to protect their execution protocols from legal challenge.
Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons, licensed under Creative Commons CC BY-SA 3.0.
This narrow focus has led to the recommendation of firing squads, with the DOJ failing to overlook the broader operational context and real-world implications that accompany use of the method. The DOJ has failed to examine who may be entrusted to enact capital punishment when a firing squad is elected, as well as the prospective executioner’s relationship with the demographic disproportionately at risk of receiving capital punishment.
For example, in Idaho, firing squads are comprised of a volunteer pool consisting of ‘peace officers’,[1] an umbrella term for law enforcement officers. A condition for volunteering in Idaho is that officers must have had “no personnel disciplinary action in the past 12 months regarding use of a firearm, use of force, or similar conduct.” This regulation is not comforting, especially as fatal force used by the police so rarely results in discipline, making a peace officer’s ‘clean’ record prove little. For example, the NAACP indicate that although police shoot and kill on average 1,000 people a year in the U.S., since 2005 only three officers have received murder convictions that have been upheld. Crucially, while attorney generals may have declared fatal shootings in the community to be a consequence of the use of ‘reasonable’ force, the communities affected usually disagree. For example, in June this year, a police sergeant in Mississippi shot at a moving vehicle containing two Black women accused of theft, resulting in the death of a one-year-old boy. The Mississippi Attorney General’s Office ruled recently that the fatal shooting of the one-year-old was ‘justified’, yet the community of Senatobia still demand justice.
If use of fatal force or problematic behaviours statistically almost never lead to discipline, an officer who has caused fatal injuries in what a community perceives to be unjust circumstances can still easily pass screening procedures for a firing squad. This is important because, for example, in Utah, when selecting firing squad volunteers, priority is given to officers from the jurisdiction where the death row prisoner committed the crime in. A situation emerges where state-sanctioned punishment, ostensibly designed to help achieve justice, is administered by members of a force that the community observe to have already behaved unjustly with little to no repercussion.
Should officers who have devastated communities with ‘reasonable’ fatal force have access to a pathway to punish in execution chambers? Evidence suggests otherwise, especially in light of unchallenged attitudes that have arguably laid the groundwork for ‘reasonable’ fatal shootings in the past. For example, the fatal shooting of Breonna Taylor by the Louisville Metro Police Department (LMPD), Kentucky, in March 2020 sparked widespread community concerns about the prevalence of institutional racism in the American police. This was especially the case as none of the officers involved were initially held responsible for her death. An investigation into the LMPD culminated in the publication of a DOJ report in 2023, which not only documented numerous instances of officers expressing racist views and using racially derogatory language, but also found that the LMPD repeatedly failed to adequately investigate or discipline officers for racial bias. This raises a broader question about whether police disciplinary records can reliably identify problematic attitudes in officers before entrusting them with the power to punish in execution chambers.
Although there is a lack of insight into the attitudes and motivations of firing squad volunteers, some have publicly shared their experiences. “I’ve shot squirrels I’ve felt worse about”, one former firing squad member and acting law enforcement officer in Utah anonymously told CNN about his experience of shooting a death row prisoner. Such desensitisation could easily stem from holding problematic views seldom caught by disciplinary procedures in the force he represents.
Considering the broader context of racial injustice and police brutality in America discussed above, is it not a gross lack of contextual awareness to entrust officers representing institutions widely criticised for abuses of power with the authority to punish in state-sanctioned executions?
The NAACP reports that Black people make up 13.4% of the U.S. population, but account for 22% of victims of fatal police shootings. As of 1 April 2026, Death Penalty Information Center data shows that 40% of death row prisoners in America are Black. Black people are overrepresented both among those killed by police and among those sentenced to death. The overlap has not gone unnoticed. Alexandra Klein notes that in 2021, South Carolina Representative Chris Hart, speaking in opposition to the adoption of firing squads, drew parallels between capital punishment and police violence against Black residents, arguing that killings like that of Walter Scott in April 2015 amounted to executions without any choice of method. Where firing squads are staffed by peace officers, those performing criminal justice do so whilst representing institutions which stand credibly accused of disproportionately enacting lethal force on Black Americans.
When the state retains the power to end a life as an irreversible punishment, irrespective of how ‘ideal’ the method, the state exercises its power against a backdrop of systemic injustice. Revival of the firing squad is a specific example of how the pursuit of a more ‘humane’ method does nothing to challenge systemic injustice in the justice system - rather, it can create conditions for systemic injustice to prosper, while avoiding addressing the fundamental problems with the death penalty.
To give a more recent example, on 8 October, U.S. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth announced plans to livestream the execution by military firing squad of Nidal Hasan. The livestreaming element has since been shelved amid bipartisan condemnation and a widespread national and international outcry, yet President Donald Trump commented that it would have been “a strong deterrent for the World to witness how America deals with Terrorists”. Fixating on the firing squad’s purported painlessness and infallibility clouds the fact that the method can, as this case demonstrates, constitute an instrument of significant state power, directly and symbolically.
Christa Pike’s case has attracted significant international scrutiny of the harms associated with using the lethal injection as an execution method. It is crucial, however, to acknowledge that all existing execution methods have either produced a botched result or have had their reliability called into question. Even the firing squad, endorsed by the DOJ as the most painless and reliable execution method, grants the pathway for an insidious type of harm, systemic racism, to prosper in the justice system. Any method of execution will inevitably operate within a system that is entrenched in injustice, which is why a revival of firing squads is not the solution to America’s problem of botched injections: only abolition of the death penalty is.
[1] Utah also selects its firing squad members from a volunteer pool comprising of peace officers, while South Carolina uses volunteer officers from the Department of Corrections. Neither Mississippi nor Oklahoma appear to have publicly published a protocol for selecting firing squad members.
| Fatime Krasniqi is an aspiring criminal barrister, soon to start the Bar Practice Course at the Inns of Court College of Advocacy (ICCA). Her experience includes working in prison education as a curriculum manager and serving as an Independent Monitoring Board member. |
Share: